Beach Walk 156 – Lucky or Smart?

Does it matter if you’re lucky or smart?

Can’t play the movie? Visit our Help page for more info.

About Today’s Show

The interview I read last week with Dr. Ben Barres mentioned something I’ve been thinking about: luck vs. accomplishment or grace vs. merit. He said he feels lucky to be teaching at Stanford, but imagines that Lawrence Summers feels deserving to be at Harvard.

I’ve often wondered how actors will thank God for their awards but business people tend to attribute success to their own making. I see a lot of holes, as you can “do all the right things” and still fail, and of course do all the “wrong things” and have a fabulous success. Clearly, there are many things outside of our control, and I find it curious that in some fields we dismiss those things so readily.

Here’s my logic. Since we cannot prove whether a result occurs exclusively from our own merit, then that means we can try the things we want! It means that if we fail at something, it may or may not have been our “fault.” I find it much more useful to observe “what worked for me, what didn’t” and “Do I want to try that again?” It is so easy to get so invested in the results, and think they actually mean something other than they are the results of this one particular task. A single experience does not measure the true relevance of any given goal and it certainly does not measure your talent or brains.

Hawaiian words
Hana: business, labor

Be in Touch!

Comments

  1. SoCalGal says:

    Wow, you had an exceptionally beautiful day. (I liked your scarf too!)

  2. Yes it was beautiful. I was just thinking that this show relates to the whole open source movement and copyright disruption that is taking place. At one far end of the spectrum, I do believe that all knowledge is shared in the universe, and that each of us are more actors playing a role than true originators. Nonetheless, we live in a world of limits and boundaries, and let’s not forget commerce. I for one am looking for new ways to acknowledge each person’s effort without taking it too seriously, as clearly, we each have the backing of a boundless Universe.